November 20, 2026

Continuing the Planar Primer, we now take a look at the differences between using magic in Planescape compared to in a regular D&D game.
We’ll start with the simple position of casting elemental spells on the elemental planes.
After, we’ll look at the effects of planar travel when your magic is gifted from a higher power.

Contents

The things I will cover across these posts will include, but are not limited to:
Part 1 – Introduction
Part 2 – Differences in Magic
Part 3 – Improving Magic & Magic Items
Part 4 – Traversal of the Planes
Part 5 – The Planes & Locations Within
Part 6 – Monstrous Modifications

We’ll start with a small vent, we have one book in 5E that covers a different plane of existence, Descent into Avernus, which lays out the differences in magic between your game on the prime material plane, and in Avernus (the Hells).
Why is there a problem here? It’s solely cosmetic, in fact here’s some appropriate information here for you from Descent into Avernus.

I had to take a screen shot, because even copying a few of the examples would be blocked through the wordpress install and I am not sure why.Originally I had copied sections of this text into a quote, but when trying to save I would encounter a 403 error on the site, remove the section and it works fine.
As such, you will have to make do with the image.
But this image details the effects of casting various spells within Avernus (spoilers: the spell looks different).

“Where is the beef?” I hear you cry, and I will tell you.
Making the changes solely thematic is the cheapest of all ways to handle the differences in magic in the Planes.
Hells, every player describes their spell differently, it’s part of how they customise their character, so not only does the design choice have no real impact, but it shows a lack of understanding of the modern playerbase, and a disdain for any real complexity in the magical system.

 

So we’re going to begin there, with magic.
In a move that I feel WotC should have done, I will bring complexity back into Planar magic, but ensure there is a way to mitigate it, give any affected spellcasters a way to overcome the trouble they will encounter.

The Great Wheel Cosmology from Dungeons and Dragons
The first step in this is familiarising ourselves with the layout of the Planes. For ease of reference for this document I am including a very basic representation of the Planes, there are however some beautiful visuals for the same data that I implore you to look up and reference.

We will begin by looking at the four elemental planes for they shall be simple, lets make this as a table for ease of use.


The Elemental Planes

Plane of Fire Plane of Air Plane of Water Plane of Earth
Fire Spells Upcast Normal Downcast Normal
Air Spells Normal Upcast Normal Downcast
Water Spells Downcast Normal Upcast Normal
Earth Spells Normal Downcast Normal Upcast

If the table isn’t clear, when you are on an elemental plane and cast a spell in line with that element, it is automatically cast at the next spell level (at no extra cost).
Similarly, when you cast an opposing spell, it is automatically cast at the previous level (at regular cost).
Spells for the other elements (or non-elemental spells) do not change, so for example in the Elemental Plane of Fire, casting Lightening Bolt is done as normal.

 

Simple, right? Though since we can start getting elemental with our spells from level one, we should also a caveat for this.
When casting a cantrip or level one spell on an opposing plane, that spell is cast with disadvantage.
When casting a level nine spell on it’s matching plane, that spell is cast with advantage

 

Now this will also apple when casting a spell in the outer planes, and I will reference back to this.

This way we still have some manner of cost for our spells, forcing a magic user to prepare differently to keep relevant through the planar journey.

For the other Planes, some spells are similarly affected as Elemental Planes affect Elemental Spells, but that will be covered in a brief description of each Plane at the end.


The Outer Planes

Next we’ve got to look at all the planes in the Outer Planes, typically the domain for gods, devils and demons.
So the premise for this part of the cosmology is where your magic comes from, if it is given to you by a specific god, devil or demon.

How do we measure magic given in the same way we did elemental magic?
We’ll start by looking at your chosen power’s source, for this example lets look at Bahamut, like all gods (in older editions, you may need a little research) Bahamut has a Home Plane, typically a location where their base or fortress can be found, for Bahamut this is Mount Celestia.
Whilst in their powers Home Plane, any cleric or paladin (or even warlock)’s connection to the source of their powers is strongest, they should have the benefit of both their spells being upcast, and advantage.
Then the neighbouring planes, one clockwise and one anti-clockwise, the connection weakens and they only receive the benefit of their spells upcast.

 

So for our example, a Cleric of Bahamut would receive the strongest boon whilst on Mount Celestia, a reduced boon on either Bytopia or Arcadia.

As we draw to the opposite side of the Great Wheel, our example Clerics powers would lessen, there are two ways we can do this and I will list them both.

Firstly, we take the exact opposite of our boons, so in The Abyss, our Cleric’s spells are downcast by a level, and they suffer disadvantage.
Then in the neighbouring planes (again, one clockwise, and one anti-clockwise) Carceri and Pandemonium, our Cleric would only have to contend with their spells being downcast at a lower level.

 

The second option, this time we take the opposing plane and two planes both clockwise and anti-clockwise (in order, Hades, Carceri, The Abyss, Pandemonium and Limbo) and in all of these locations our Cleric would suffer their magic downcast by a level.
This way, the Cleric would not have too harsh a punishment but still suffer for being away from their deity’s sphere of influence.

 

Similarly, if you were a Warlock making your pact with the Myrkul, your Home Plane is Hades, and there you would gain the biggest boon, in it’s neighbours (Carceri and Gehenna) you would still have a benefit.
Then depending on which variant you play, you would either suffer in Bytopia, Elysium and The Beastlands, or you would add Mount Celestia and Aborea to the list.

 

The reason why I like this opposing powers setup for magic in the planes is simply that it makes sense on multiple levels, and is easy enough to follow.
But on top of this, it would be easy enough to draw a brief guide on a print out, using just a ruler and a highlighter.

 

What if my Power isn’t from an Outer Plane?

Now personally my current caster is a Paladin of Gond, so where does Gond fit into the great wheel? Great question, they don’t.
Gond’s domain is in the Outlands, the realm closest to Sigil at the heart of the wheel (I know, it isn’t included in the graphic above, but it’s hard to really place it in a 2D image).
With this in mind, how do we fit a follower of Gond into this system? Simply, they would get to upcast their spells in Outlands, and have to downcast their spells in all of the Outer Planes.
This by far makes them most likely to be at a disadvantage compared to any other caster, but fits thematically.

 

If your Caster’s Power doesn’t have a home plane listed, either select the one that fits their alignment best or decide with your DM in which location they would be most active.

 

What about Level 1 and Level 9 Spells?

Here is where we reference back to our previous note under element planes.

When you are on a plane that opposes the source of your power, and you attempt to cast either a cantrip or level one spell, we need to make a small difference.

When our follow of Bahamut casts a level one spell in The Abyss, we can’t exactly downcast it (and if you’re using Magic Variant Rule #1, you already have disadvantage), so what do we do?

 

Simply, we make it a requirement that the spell be cast at Level 2, that the Level 1 spell slot is unable to be used as if the connection to the powers source has become strained.

 

Similarly, a level nine spell cast on the homeplane of our power, cannot be further upcast and though I would be hesitant to power it up further I can understand why you might want that in an effort to make your characters feel epic on their home plane.

As such, we will leave Level 9 spell slots alone, you can’t further upcast, you can’t gain additional benefit, but you can still use the slot to cast your spells at Level 9.

 

Now, if you’re thinking that this is a little too complicated for you just based off my description and that is fine, I made a tool that will help.

 

One last Question

So, you’re probably asking “My Power’s home is Toril, how does this affect their spells in Krynn”, which is a valid question and one that wasn’t covered in the latest Spelljammer release.
It’s simple, being on a different Material Plane doesn’t affect your ability to cast spells, what you do have trouble with is regaining spells gaining only half your maximum spell slots (rounded up) on every appropriate rest but this only applies if your power doesn’t have influence on that plane.
This is where you need to hit up your favourite search engine and type in something like “Bahamut on krynn”, which should show you if Bahamut has any influence on Krynn, in this example our Cleric of Bahamut would regain all of their power on a trip to Krynn, because Bahamut is active in the world, under the name Paladine.

You might be asking why I am throwing in this kind of rule when it feels out of left-field for the rest of the magic rules for Planescape and the answer (I realise I say this a lot) is simple, it is a rule taken out of Spelljammer, and if you plan to visit all of the Material Planes it is the rule I would use.

 

Finally

Next we should consider the final question you’re going to have when it comes to the topic of magic in the Planes.
“Why would anyone want to play this?”
Okay, so I am not going to answer that directly, but I do have an answer for you.

You can fix your broken spells.
But that is a topic for next time.

6 thoughts on “A Brief Primer for Planar Travel pt2 – Magical Differences”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *